Who gets the first-day pop
Jay Ritter at the University of Florida has tracked 9,253 US listings from 1980 to 2024. He counts operating companies only, so shell companies and tiny listings under $5 a share are left out. On average the shares rose 18.9% on their first day.
Buy at the first-day close, hold for three years, and the average return was 19.1%. Over the same stretches the market made roughly 40%, so you were 20.5 percentage points behind.
Buy at the offer price and the three-year return was 36.3%, only 3.3 points behind the market. The difference between those two results is the first day.
Banks decide who gets shares at the offer price, and they usually set that price a little below where they expect trading to start, so the people they allocate to begin with a profit. It keeps the buyers coming back for the next deal. Most ordinary investors buy afterwards, from people who've just been allocated shares cheaper.
Some online brokers now let you place an order before trading starts, which feels like getting in early. It's filled at the market price once trading opens, so on Thursday that meant paying around $111.50 for a share the banks had sold at $83.
And remember who's selling. A company and its early backers pick the date, and they want buyers keen and prices high when they do. A record-sized listing tells you how much they think the market will pay, which is a different question from how the company will do.
Why we're glad of a pullback
We'd much rather see this than a market that only goes up. When prices rise in a straight line, people borrow to buy more, and the price ends up depending on nobody getting nervous. A fall like this one clears some of that out and leaves prices lower for whoever buys next.
Most of our clients are whoever buys next. Saving monthly into a fund, or rebalancing to a target mix, means buying more when prices drop. A pullback in the most expensive corner of the market helps you, even though the next statement won't look like it.
If you still want to own a company that's just listed, keep it small next to everything else. SpaceX fell nearly half in seven weeks, so size it for that. Decide before you buy what would make you sell, because nobody thinks clearly while the price is swinging the way Anthropic's did on Thursday.
You don't have to chase Anthropic on day one to own some of it anyway. Under a Nasdaq rule rewritten this year with listings like SpaceX in mind, funds that track the Nasdaq-100 index have to buy very large new listings after about 15 trading days.
Visa's lucky buyers didn't have a better tip than anyone else. They bought when everyone else was too scared to.
If you'd like a plan built around what you need from your money, rather than whatever's listing this week, you can book an initial call below.